European Journal of Information SystemsVolume 31, Issue 3, Pages 269 - 2872022

Theorising Algorithmic Justice

  • a University of Technology, Sydney Faculty of Engineering and Information Technology, School of Professional Practice & Leadership, Sydney, Australia
  • b University of New South Wales Business School, Sydney, Australia
  • c University of Hull, School of Management, United Kingdom
384th percentile
Citations in Scopus
1.61
FWCI

Abstract

The mounting evidence of unintended harmful social consequences of automated algorithmic decision-making (AADM), powered by AI and big data, in transformative services (e.g., welfare services), is startling. The algorithmic harm experienced by individuals, communities and society-at-large involves new injustice claims and disputes that go beyond issues of social justice. Drawing from the theory of “abnormal justice” in this paper we articulate a new theory of algorithmic justice that addresses the questions: WHAT is the matter of algorithmic justice? WHO counts as a subject of algorithmic justice? HOW are algorithmic justices performed? and How to address and resolve disputes about the WHAT, WHO and HOW of algorithmic justice? We illustrate the theory of algorithmic justice by drawing from a case of AADM in social welfare services, widely adopted by governments around the world. Our research points to datafication, technological inscribing and the systemic nature of injustices as important IS-specific aspects of algorithmic justice. Our main practical contribution comes from the articulation of algorithmic justice as a framework that (1) makes visible the injustices related to the “what”, “who”, and “how” of AADM in transformative services, and (2) provides further insights into how we might address and resolve these algorithmic injustices. © Operational Research Society 2021.

Author keywords

datafication; Harmful effects of automated algorithmic decision-making; Patrick Mikalef, Aleš Popovic, Jenny Eriksson Lundström and Kieran Conboy; systemic algorithmic injustices; technological inscribing; theory of algorithmic justice

  Marjanovic, O.; University of Technology, Sydney Faculty of Engineering and Information Technology, School of Professional Practice & Leadership, Sydney, Australia; email:Olivera.Marjanovic@uts.edu.au
© Copyright 2022 Elsevier B.V., All rights reserved.